I came across this video when I was doing some research on
alternative ways to learn a language.
Just watch the first five minutes.
OK, I am sure there is a lot of criticism on Pimsleur’s
method and I am quite skeptical of it.
(Comparing a child’s ability to soak up languages with an adult is like
comparing a genius’s ability to learn aerospace engineering with mine!) It reminds me of the scene from Back to School with Rodney Dangerfield
who learns French by listening to headphones while he sleeps.
I am not so interested in the Pimsleur Approach as I am in the criticism this video offers for the way we teach
language. I thought a discussion
on what experiences we have had on what works, and, perhaps more interestingly,
what doesn’t work would be helpful. For example I am a Russian speaker, but I
learned Russian from speaking it with people, not from learning it in a
class. This has had certain limitations,
such as my constant difficulty with word endings; however, my accent and
vocabulary are much better than someone who learned the language in a
classroom. On the other hand, I
have tried numerous times to learn Spanish in the classroom, but feel there is
always a ceiling I hit very early on.
I get bored with the worksheets; I never have practice; I never improve.
Some questions to consider: What experiences (good and bad) have
you had learning a language? In what ways does the classroom get in the way of
real language learning? Does the
way we teach language in K-12 have anything to do with the reasons why students
in the USA have such difficulty learning a language?
